Replacement cost pricing means you price a part from what it will cost you to buy the next one, not from what you paid for the one already on the truck. For a contractor's price book, replacement cost is the safest number to enter: an older purchase cost or a running average lags behind supplier increases, so every sale at the old cost quietly comes in below your target margin. Keep the average for your books and the replacement cost for your prices.
What is replacement cost pricing for contractors?
Replacement cost is the price your supplier would charge you today to restock an artículo: the current quote, price sheet or most recent invoice, converted to the unit you sell, plus any freight you allocate to it. Replacement cost pricing uses that number as the cost basis in your price book, then applies your markup or margin target on top.
The alternative is pricing from historical cost, meaning what you actually paid for the specific part that goes into the job. The problem is timing. A part bought in January and installed in September is sold at September prices, but if your price book still carries January's cost, the selling price is set from a number you can no longer buy at.
This matters most for the stock you carry: capacitors, contactors, fittings, wire and other parts that sit on shelves and trucks for weeks or months. For special-order equipment bought for one job, the purchase cost and the replacement cost are usually the same invoice.
Which cost should go in your price book: last cost, average cost or replacement cost?
There are four common choices for the cost field on a stocked artículo. Each answers a different question:
- Oldest stocked cost (FIFO). The cost of the oldest units still on hand. Useful for valuing inventory; worst for pricing when costs are rising.
- Weighted average cost. Total paid for the units on hand divided by the number of units. Smooths out swings, but always trails a rising market.
- Last paid cost. The most recent invoice. Close to current, but only as fresh as your last purchase.
- Replacement cost. Today's quote from your supplier. The only one that tells you what restocking will cost.
The worked example below shows how much margin each choice gives up. A shop buys 10 contactors at $40 in January and 10 more at $44 in May. Four January units and all ten May units are still on hand. The supplier's current quote is $48. The shop targets a 50% material margin, so the selling price is cost ÷ (1 − 0.50), which is cost × 2. (If the difference between margin and markup is fuzzy, this markup vs margin explainer covers it.)
| Cost basis (worked example) | Cost used | Margen de Selling price at 50% | Gross profit if restocked at $48 | Real margin at replacement cost |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Oldest stocked cost (FIFO) | $40.00 | $80.00 | $32.00 | 40.0% |
| Weighted average (4 × $40, 10 × $44) | $42.86 | $85.71 | $37.71 | 44.0% |
| Last paid cost | $44.00 | $88.00 | $40.00 | 45.5% |
| Replacement cost (current quote) | $48.00 | $96.00 | $48.00 | 50.0% |
Every basis except replacement cost misses the 50% target, because the money from each sale has to buy a $48 contactor to refill the shelf. Pricing from the oldest cost gives up $16 of gross profit on every unit, a third of the $48 the shop planned to earn. Use the Calculadora de margen y recargo to run the same check on your own numbers.
Why does average cost lag behind supplier price increases?
An average includes every older, cheaper purchase in the window it covers, so when prices climb for months in a row, the average is always below what you pay today. The longer the window, the bigger the gap.
Copper wire shows how big that gap can get. The U.S. Bureau of Labor Statistics Producer Price Index for copper wire and cable rose from 464.522 in September 2025 to 607.705 in September 2026 (preliminary), an increase of 30.8%. The PPI measures prices producers receive, not your supply house's price, so treat it as the direction and speed of change, not your invoice.
The table applies that index to an illustrative wire roll whose replacement cost today is $150, priced at a 50% margin target:
| Cost basis tracking the copper wire PPI | Index value | Below latest month | Roll cost used | Margen de Price at 50% | Real margin at $150 replacement |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| 12-month average (Oct 2025–Sep 2026) | 546.185 | 10.1% | $134.82 | $269.63 | 44.4% |
| 6-month average (Apr–Sep 2026) | 577.485 | 5.0% | $142.54 | $285.08 | 47.4% |
| 3-month average (Jul–Sep 2026) | 596.353 | 1.9% | $147.20 | $294.40 | 49.1% |
| Latest month (Sep 2026) | 607.705 | 0.0% | $150.00 | $300.00 | 50.0% |
Source: BLS PPI series WPU10260314, not seasonally adjusted, retrieved November 2, 2026. June through September 2026 values are preliminary and can be revised for up to four months. Averages are simple means of the monthly index values; roll costs scale $150 by each average ÷ the September index.
A 12-month average would have the shop pricing that roll more than $30 below its replacement-cost price.
How do ServiceTitan and Jobber handle material cost?
Both platforms keep a cost on each catalog artículo, and they differ in how that number gets updated.
ServiceTitan offers two inventory costing methods, according to its help article "Set an inventory costing method" (updated October 15, 2026). Standard costing, the default, uses the cost listed for the artículo's primary vendor in the pricebook. Weighted average costing uses the average paid on bills during the last 30 days and requires the Inventory module. A separate article notes that ServiceTitan doesn't push a bill's cost back into the lista de precios unless someone turns on the Update Pricebook option while creating the bill. If bills are created automatically, the pricebook cost stays where it was.
Jobber keeps a single unit cost per product or service, on plans that include markup. Its Products & Services help article (updated October 29, 2026) says that when new costs are imported without updating the unit price, "the price will remain the same and the markup will be adjusted." In other words, a cost update alone does not reprice the artículo. Your margin shrinks until you change the price.
Either way, the price book cost is whatever someone last entered. The software will not choose between last month's average and today's quote for you.
Is replacement cost pricing allowed for taxes and accounting?
Yes, because pricing and inventory accounting are separate decisions. Your selling price is a business choice. How you value inventory on your tax return follows accounting rules. IRS Publication 538 describes identifying inventory cost with the specific identification, FIFO or LIFO methods. None of those rules tell you what to charge a customer.
A practical split for a small shop: let your accountant and accounting software value inventory with whatever method you have adopted, and keep replacement cost in the price book. Ask your accountant before you change an inventory method, because changing one can require IRS approval.
How do you keep replacement costs current in a price book?
Replacement cost only protects margin if it is refreshed. A workable routine:
- Pick the artículos that matter. Your 20–50 highest-volume stocked parts, plus anything with a commodity input such as copper, steel or refrigerant.
- Get a dated number. Use a supplier quote, price sheet or the latest invoice, and record the date next to the cost. Convert pack prices to the unit you sell: a 10-pack at $30 is $3 each.
- Update cost, then review price. A schedule-driven price follows the new cost. A price you typed in by hand does not, in most systems. Check both, and do not enter a zero or a guess for a part you could not price. Missing and blank costs need their own fix.
- Set a cadence. Monthly spot checks on fast movers and a full pass each quarter fit most shops. The price book audit guide covers the full checklist, and adjusting prices when material costs rise walks through the repricing math for a single increase.
- Compare against actuals. Costeo de trabajos shows when material lines on finished jobs cost more than the price book assumed.
If you use a markup schedule, replacement cost also keeps parts in the right rango de costos. A part whose real cost moved from $48 to $55 might belong in a different band than its stale cost suggests.
En Pricebookr, an artículo's cost is material plus labor. A supplier change can be applied to material cost only, and the preview lists every row's old and new cost before anything is saved. Prices you set by hand stay fixed until you choose to change them.
Conclusión clave: Use replacement cost for prices, and whatever method your accountant uses for inventory. In the worked example above, pricing a $48 part from a $40 old cost gave up a third of the planned gross profit on every sale.
Preguntas frecuentes
What is replacement cost pricing?
Replacement cost pricing sets a selling price from what it would cost to buy the artículo again today, rather than what was paid for the unit in stock. A contractor enters the current supplier quote or latest invoice as the price book cost, converted to the selling unit, and applies a markup or margin target. When supplier costs rise, it keeps each sale funding the next purchase.
Should contractors use average cost or replacement cost in their price book?
Use replacement cost for pricing. Weighted average cost blends older, cheaper purchases into the number, so it trails behind supplier increases and every sale lands below the target margin. In a worked example with a $48 replacement cost and a 50% target, pricing from a $42.86 average delivered a 44% margin. Keep average or FIFO cost for inventory valuation and accounting.
How often should I update material costs in my price book?
Spot-check your highest-volume and commodity-sensitive parts monthly, and review the full price book at least once a quarter. Update sooner when a supplier sends a new price sheet or a commodity index moves sharply. The U.S. PPI for copper wire and cable rose 30.8% from September 2025 to September 2026, so wire costs entered a year ago would be far behind.
Does updating a cost automatically change the selling price?
Only if the price is calculated from cost. In Jobber, importing a new unit cost without a new unit price leaves the price unchanged and lowers the markup. In most price books, a price typed in by hand stays fixed when cost changes, while a price set by a markup rule follows the new cost. After any cost update, check which of your prices actually moved.